If
you wish to return to the 'Ask Dr. Dunc.' mainpage, please click
here
If
you wish to visit the 'Ask Dr. Dunc.' question archives, please
click here
Question 66: Hello there my name is A., I'm
a 17 yr. old student in Australia who has recently been diagnosed
with TS....It has been rumoured that Mozart had tourette syndrome,
I wonder could this have been the source of his creative genius....What
evidence is there, if any of a link between TS and creativity?. The
other question I want to ask you is, what is a mental tic. Would echolalia
be an example of a mental tic? Maybe all mental illnesses are a form
of tic disorder? A.A., Australia.
Good evening
A.!
While
there is no research that I know of (yet) linking TS and creativity,
this link most certainly exists. Given the urgency in the research community
to find cures and understand genetics, there is scant little time for
more "positive" projects unfortunately.
In my
presentations I delve quite heavily into the connection. My thought
is that in a brain without many "brakes", there is a higher
probability that two (or more) unassociated thoughts will fire simultaneously,
become associated, and be the basis for original new ideas, compositions,
or pieces of art. I speak a bit about this in one of my T(r)IC(k)S
articles: number 9 (The Positives of Disinhibition
Part I).
With respect to "mental tics", echolalia is an example of
a complex phonic ("noise") tic, but technically because all
tics come from the brain ALL tics are, in a sense, mental tics. There
is not a recognized "mental tic" category, persey, so probably
different people using this term define it in different ways. One definition
of "mental tic" may be very similar to an obsession (a thought
that repeats over and over, and usually requires a compulsion or ritual
to be performed to help satiate the anxiety behind it). My own definition
of a "cognitive tic" is a thought that, instead of being anxiety-provoking
and resulting in a ritual-like behaviour, is more a thought about a
particular physical discomfort (being stabbed, or having a heart attack)
that leads to a tic-like behaviour (usually imitating the imagined discomfort).
While not all disorders involve "tics" in the traditional
sense, certainly many disorders (particularly those associated with
TS) tend to be about "braking" problems -- the brakes over
your movements (TS), attention (ADHD), thoughts (OCD), sensory input
(SID), emotions (bipolar), etc. In these types of disorders, what is
usually "disordered" isn't the particular thing that the person
is doing, but rather when, how often, how long, and how intensely he
or she is doing it. Many tics are "normal" movements in the
proper context.........in addition everyone gets stuck on a thought
or has a hard time paying attention sometimes. It's when these things
happen spontaneously, all the time, to a severe degree, and cannot be
well regulated that it is defined as a "disorder".
I hope this helps, A. All the best to you in your journey! Take good
care -- I'm rooting for you.
